doom and gloom from the WSJ, and just the opposite from fuse#8

Every now and then the media decides that the novel is on the decline and they might as well hold a funeral right now. The Wall Street Journal is doing that today with an article on how memoirs are in, and novels are out.

Of course there’s no hard data. It’s all spicy little anecdotes. I am amazed, really, at the degree to which some journalists buy into their own sense of power. The WSJ declares the novel dead, and so it must be. Put down that copy of Pride and Prejudice (not you, Beth. you keep reading) and pick up a memoir. Forget that Byatt has a new novel out, you want to read James Frey’s memoirs… oh. Those memoirs turned out to be fiction, didn’t they.

I’m never following a link to the WSJ again. I’d much rather read weblogs written by librarians. For example, fuse#8, who has the best job of any librarian I’ve ever come across. She works in the Donnell Central Children’s Room in Manhattan. And who is there working with her? Winnie the Pooh. The original. The real. She has a lot of interesting news about children’s books, and she writes wonderful, thoughtful reviews.

5 Replies to “doom and gloom from the WSJ, and just the opposite from fuse#8”

  1. Huh-uh. You can’t make me keep reading, nyah. But I did put it down in favor of another novel, because I have very little interest in anybuody’s memoirs. Except fictitious ones.

  2. Byatt has a new novel out? Goody……..Something to do while waiting for yours.
    Cynthia in Florida

  3. Now why would i want to read a memoir when the reason I love to read is to escape life for awhile? Very few people have led lives interesting enough to even think about bothering with.Even then, most of their lives are bound to be as boring as the rest of ours.

Comments are closed.